TIDY vs Handy
Compare a gig marketplace with lock-in commitments and cancellation fees to a flexible full management platform with a dedicated human account manager.
No Commitments. No Cancellation Fees.
Dedicated account manager | Full property management | Your pros, your rules
Get Started with TIDYTIDY is Better Than Handy if You...
Don't want to be locked into 3-12 month subscription commitments.
Don't want to pay $99 if you need to cancel a booking.
Want to use your own trusted pros, not whoever the platform assigns.
Need full property management, not just one-off task bookings.
Want a dedicated human account manager who knows your properties.
Want digital checklists so your pros know exactly what to do.
Want access to the widest pro network with total customization.
Want modern management tools — manage your properties like it's 2026, not 1996.
Handy is a gig marketplace that connects customers with independent contractors for cleaning and handyman tasks. It operates on subscription plans with multi-month minimum commitments and charges a $99 fee if you cancel a booking within 24 hours. Workers are assigned by the platform, giving you limited control over who shows up.
TIDY takes a completely different approach. TIDY is a full management platform with a dedicated human account manager, the widest pro network, and total customization. You use your own trusted pros or find new ones with Smart Pro Search. No subscription commitments, no cancellation penalties — just a modern platform that handles cleaning, maintenance, and property management your way.
The Real Cost: TIDY vs Handy
Handy's subscription plans come with multi-month commitments and steep cancellation penalties. Here's how the two platforms actually compare on cost:
TIDY
- ✓See your full price before booking
- ✓No monthly subscription required
- ✓No multi-month commitments
- ✓No $99 cancellation fees
- ✓Just 3.9% — save 90% vs traditional property managers
Handy
- →Subscription plans from $39/month (1 cleaning) to $72/month (2 cleanings)
- →3 to 12 month minimum commitments required
- →$99 fee for canceling a booking within 24 hours
- →Regular cleaning rates ~$35-65/hour depending on market
- →Workers assigned by platform — limited choice
The Bottom Line on Handy Pricing
Handy's subscription model locks you into multi-month commitments before you even know if the service works for you. Cancel a booking within 24 hours? That's a $99 fee. With TIDY, there are no subscriptions, no commitments, and no cancellation penalties. You see the real price before you book, and you pay it — no surprises. TIDY's management fee is just 3.9%, saving you 90% compared to traditional property managers.
This is based on the best publicly available data at the time of writing. If any of this information has changed or is inaccurate, please let us know.
Compare Features
| Feature | TIDY | Handy |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Subscription | ✓ None required | $39-72/month plans |
| Commitment Period | ✓ No contracts | 3 to 12 month minimums |
| Cancellation Fees | ✓ None | $99 fee for late cancellation |
| Choose Your Own Pro | ✓ Works with any pro | Platform assigns workers |
| Dedicated Account Manager | ✓ Human account manager | ✗ No |
| Property Management | ✓ Full cleaning + maintenance management | Task-by-task only |
| Digital Checklists | ✓ Custom checklists with photos | ✗ No |
| Smart Pro Search | ✓ Find pros matched to your needs | Limited to platform workers |
| Pro Network | ✓ Widest network — more pros than any competitor | Platform-assigned only |
| Customization | ✓ Total control — more settings than any platform | Limited booking options |
| Service Types | ✓ Cleaning, maintenance, and more | Cleaning, assembly, handyman |
| Track Record | ✓ 12+ years, 100K+ customers | Part of Angi/IAC family |
What Makes TIDY Different
TIDY isn't a gig marketplace that assigns workers and charges you penalties. TIDY is a full management platform with a dedicated human account manager, the widest pro network, and total customization.
A Dedicated Human Account Manager
TIDY pairs you with a real person who knows your properties and coordinates everything for you. Need to handle a last-minute change or resolve an issue? Your account manager is there — something no gig marketplace offers.
Full Property Management
Handy focuses on individual task bookings. TIDY manages cleaning, maintenance, and everything your property needs from one platform — scheduling, communication, quality tracking, all handled for you.
Your Pros, Your Rules
TIDY works with your existing pros — they won't even know you're using it. Or use Smart Pro Search to find new pros matched to your specific needs. You choose who works on your property, not the platform.
Total Customization
TIDY offers more settings and control options than any other platform. Customize schedules, checklists, communication preferences, and management workflows to fit exactly how you want things done.
Widest Pro Network
Access more pros than any competitor. Whether you need cleaning, maintenance, handyman work, or specialized services, TIDY connects you with the right pro for the job.
Transparent, Honest Pricing
No subscriptions, no cancellation fees, no surprises. See your full price before you book. Just 3.9% management fee — save 90% vs traditional property managers. No contracts, no hidden fees.
Why Commitments and Penalties Don't Work
Handy requires multi-month subscription commitments and charges a $99 fee if you cancel a booking within 24 hours. This model creates friction at every step — you feel locked in before you know if the service works, and penalized when life inevitably changes your plans.
We believe a better approach is to earn your business with great service, not lock-in. TIDY has no subscription commitments, no cancellation penalties, and no hidden fees. If TIDY isn't working for you, you can stop anytime. That's the way it should be.
When platforms rely on lock-in rather than quality, the incentive shifts from keeping you happy to keeping you committed. TIDY's model is simple: provide a great management platform with a dedicated account manager, the widest pro network, and total customization — and trust that you'll stay because it works, not because you're trapped.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does TIDY require a subscription like Handy?
Does TIDY charge cancellation fees?
Can I choose my own cleaner with TIDY?
Does TIDY only do cleaning like Handy?
How does TIDY pricing compare to Handy?
Is TIDY available in my area?
Ready to Try a Better Approach?
Full property management with a dedicated account manager. No subscription commitments. No cancellation fees. Just modern management that works.
Disclaimer: This comparison was created as of March 2026 using the best available public data at the time, including information from handy.com, their terms of service, and their pricing page. A "No" indicates a feature we could not confirm through publicly available information. We strive to make this accurate and fair — if you see any issues or inaccuracies, please let us know and we'll correct them promptly. TIDY is not affiliated, associated, authorized, endorsed by, or in any way officially connected with Handy, and all trademarks remain their property. Before making decisions, customers should conduct independent research.